If part of your firm's marketing plan includes earning new clients from organic search, you probably track things like your sites' traffic, rankings and inquiries. You might also track your online competitors. After all, competitive analysis can be a very effective way to identify what other people are doing that is working. But, if you're like many lawyers and legal marketers, you probably focus on other law firms. But here's the thing, your greatest competition online is probably not other law firms. No, your biggest online competition probably comes from online legal directories.
Here's a snapshot of sites that have the most coverage for a group of 32 personal injury related terms across both desktops and smartphones in four major markets: New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and Houston.
For this group of 32 personal injury terms, in these markets, for the 320 SERPs that were analyzed, Avvo.com has a top-ten ranking in Google 7.19% of the time. This is the highest for any site. In aggregate these sites, none of them law firm sites, have a top-ten ranking in Google 32.51% of the time.
Obviously, this is a limited data set and your results may be much different for your target keywords and locations. However, my guess is that these sites dominate your SERPs too. And this trend is likely to continue until Google fixes Pigeon and dials back the impact of domain authority.
So, what can be done. Can you compete with these sites in organic search? Generally, at a very high-level, probably not. The resources invested into getting these sites to appear prominently in search results easily eclipses those of the overwhelming majority of law firms. However, on a hyper-local level, you can even the playing field.
The first advantage law firms have over these sites is Google My Business. This is why it should be on your firm's short SEO Checklist. Major legal directory sites can't create Google My Business pages. And notice that google.com is one of the domains listed above. This is largely attributable to Google Maps visibility on smartphones:
The second advantage that law firms have is that they're local. While legal directory sites want to appear "everywhere," most law firms only really need to be visible to their local target audience. So, they can target more local terms on their most authoritative pages (like their home pages). Notice that in the above example three of the top-ten results belong to actual law firms and the page that ranks is the firm's home page. In contrast, the directory sites are ranking internal location + practice area pages. In other words, the firms only need to "beat" the relevant directory pages which are likely to have less authority.
Finally, if you can't beat them, join them. Get your profile listed prominently on the specific legal directory pages that appear prominently for your target terms. This might mean optimizing your profiles within these sites. It might also mean advertising on the sites. While many law firms complain that legal directory advertising is largely ineffective, it's usually because they haven't been strategic about their advertising and aren't closely tracking results (i.e return on ad spend, etc). If Yelp.com ranks prominently for your target keywords, you should probably investigate whether a highly-visible ad on that page would convert for your firm.
The next time you perform a competitive analysis of your target SERPs, make sure you include all of the sites that appear prominently for your target terms, not just other law firms.
On April 22, 2025, Google sent an email updating Local Services Ads Additional Terms for Providers: Subject: Action required: important updates to Local Service Ads Additional Terms Many people are arguing that lawyers cannot participate in Local Services Ads, as this would constitute a per se violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct related to […]
Conrad and I recently joined Zack at Lawyerist to record a conversation about AI and marketing. You might think that we spend the whole time on how lawyers can use AI to publish content. You'd be wrong. While AI can certainly support publishing, there are many more interesting ways to use it in legal marketing. […]
As more legal services consumers turn to ChatGPT for local law firm recommendations, a fascinating intersection between AI, search, and maps unfolds. While Google remains the undisputed leader in local business data, ChatGPT is increasingly becoming an entry point for searchers seeking legal representation. But here’s the kicker: instead of keeping users within its ecosystem, […]
When law firms contact us, they usually want to talk: • PPC Ads • SEO Rankings • Lead Generation Very few want to talk: • Brand • Trust & Recognition • Emotional Connection Admittedly, much of this concerns that AttorneySync is known for lead generation across those common digital channels. But even when we start […]
According to an October 2024 study by SE Ranking: "The legal niche triggers the highest percentage of AIOs (77.67%). The average number of links matched between the AI Overview resources and the top 20 search results was 6.49 for legal topics. AI Overviews for legal topics most frequently link to NYCourts.gov (114 links), YouTube.com (48 […]
I'm grateful for my friend, Charley Mann of Law firm Alchemy. If you're a lawyer, subscribe to his Free Email List. In a recent email, Charley calls out bad guru advice on hiring: "Trying to execute a major SEO improvement? You need to find people who will help you, instead of trying to DIY it […]
If you’ve spent any time on LinkedIn, you’ve likely seen posts from law firm SEO experts showing off charts with an “up and to the right” trajectory. These screenshots, often pulled from tools like Semrush or Ahrefs, are meant to signal SEO success. And it’s not just the agencies celebrating—𝗹𝗮𝘄 𝗳𝗶𝗿𝗺𝘀 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗵𝗮𝘃𝗲 𝗵𝗶𝗿𝗲𝗱 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗺 […]
Meh, links! All things being equal, links still tend to move the dial more than any other factor in legal SERPs. Maybe links are having a diminishing impact internet-wide. But in my experience, quality links, especially relevant links (both topically and geographically), tend to improve law firm visibility in search more than most everything else. […]
When you think of "marketing," what's the first thing that comes to mind? Ads? SEO? Social Media? What about: Helping others?Taking the lead? Rallying around your community? Need an example? Learn from Bart Siniard at Siniard Law Injury Attorneys efforts to help rebuild Mary's Pit BBQ. These efforts aren't about marketing. They're about supporting a […]
Great Post GYI! It seems like common sense to have your profile on these properties but i often still get push back! Crazy.
Thanks for stopping in Susan. I feel your pain. I think a lot of the negative sentiment has been earned from lawyers' historical experiences with directories. And there are plenty of instances where paying for a directory listings / advertisement is a complete waste. But there's little doubt, especially post-pigeon, that directories attract eyeballs from search. And in at least some cases, for some firms, they can generate ROAS.