"But What's Our ROI?" Plaintiff Firms and the Wrong Timeframe

President, AttorneySync

Series: Planning law firm marketing for 2027, part 5 of 7. "But what's our ROI?" with a timeline from case signed in 2027 to fee paid around 2029, 18 to 36+ months later.

This is part five of a series on planning law firm marketing for 2027. Start with part one if you’re just joining.

Every partner wants to know which channel has the best ROI.

Great question.

Wrong timeframe.

Plaintiff firms don’t get paid when they sign a case. They get paid when it resolves. For a lot of PI firms, that’s 18 months to three years later. Litigated and catastrophic cases take longer.

So, ROI on the 2027 plan compares this year’s spend against fees from cases signed two, three, or four years ago, under a different budget and channel mix. Maybe even a different Google.

Seems problematic.

It leads to bad calls. Cutting a channel that’s signing great cases because the fees haven’t landed yet. Doubling down on one because a big settlement came in this year from a case signed in 2023.

Don’t get me wrong. Over the long run, ROI is the most important question there is.

But look at it by cohort. Track every case by the year it was signed and the channel it came from. Then follow each cohort as fees come in.

After a few years, our made-up example firm might (hypothetically) learn something like this:

  • Google Ads cases cost more but skew toward higher-value auto cases.
  • LSA cases cost less, but more get declined or turn out lower-value. (Limited control over which searches trigger the ads doesn’t help.)
  • TV looks expensive per case, but branded search, referrals, and conversion rates all climbed after it started.

That should shape how much the firm is willing to pay per case in each channel. A $6,000 case from a channel averaging $30,000 in fees beats a $3,000 case from a channel averaging $9,000.

But it moves slowly. Look at it once or twice a year.

For the annual plan and the weekly Scorecard, I’d keep it to two questions.

How many new cases did we sign?

What did each one cost, blended and by channel (where we can measure it)?

You can see those inside a year. And they’re leading indicators of the fees that show up later.

One warning. Cost per case is easy to game.

Sign a bunch of property-damage-only fender benders and your cost per case looks amazing. 🫣

So, add a quality check to the Scorecard. Something like the percentage of cases that meet your minimum criteria.

Don’t have years of clean case data by source yet? You’re not alone.

Start tracking it now. Future you will be grateful.

Next up: Don’t Buy Growth You Can’t Serve (coming Sunday, Nov. 22)

Let's talk

Let's discuss your growth.

Tell us about your firm and your goals. If we can profitably deliver value, we will show you how.

Prefer to talk now? Call 773-828-8878

By providing a telephone number and submitting the form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.